
Photo: Lepakshi Nandi, Rahmanuddin, CC BY-SA 4.0
APPSC Group-I Mains 2023 · Paper II
2023 Paper II · Q10(a): model answer
History, Culture & Geography of India and Andhra Pradesh · United Andhra Pradesh and the 2014 Split. Held in June 2023 (Notification 28/2022).
Explain the inconsistencies of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act 2014 that had adversely affected the residuary state of Andhra Pradesh with regards to apportionment of assets and liabilities.
Syllabus: United Andhra Pradesh and the 2014 Split · AP Reorganisation Act 2014: assets, employees, water
AP Reorganisation Act 2014Assets and liabilitiesPopulation ratioRevenue deficit
The Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014 created Telangana on 2 June 2014. Residuary Andhra Pradesh got about 58% of the population but lost Hyderabad, the hub of revenue, industry and state-level institutions. The Act's mixed rules for dividing assets and liabilities (location for some items, population for others, headquarters for still others) left AP with more debt than assets and a long tail of disputes.
| Item | Rule in the Act | Effect on AP |
|---|---|---|
| Land, buildings and other immovable assets | Go to the state where located | Most state-level assets, being in Hyderabad, went to Telangana |
| Debt and pensions | Broadly the population ratio (58.32 : 41.68) | AP took the larger share of liabilities |
| Schedule IX companies and corporations (about 90) | Assets linked to headquarters | Headquarters mostly in Hyderabad; long disputes |
| Schedule X institutions (over 100) | Only continuation of services for a limited period | No clear rule on assets; APSCHE funds case |
| Capital | Hyderabad common capital for ten years (Section 5) | AP to build a new capital with central support (Section 94) |
1. Inconsistencies in apportionment
- Mixed principles: land and immovable assets pass to the state where they are located, but debt and pensions are divided broadly on the population ratio; with most state-level assets in Hyderabad, AP got more liabilities than assets.
- Headquarters rule: assets of Schedule IX companies and corporations (about 90 bodies) are linked to their headquarters, mostly in Hyderabad; disputes over what 'headquarters' covers stalled the division, and the Sheela Bhide expert committee's recommendations were only partly implemented.
- Schedule X gap: for these institutions (over 100) the Act provided only for continuing their services for a limited period, with no clear rule on assets; the dispute over the funds of the AP State Council of Higher Education reached the Supreme Court.
- Need ignored: dividing liabilities by population took no account of revenue capacity, so the State with the smaller tax base carried the larger debt.
- Revenue mismatch: Hyderabad's large tax base went to Telangana while AP inherited a larger pension and debt burden, leading to a revenue deficit from the first year that required central grants.
2. Other adverse effects
- Power dues: dues for electricity supplied by AP Genco to Telangana's discoms (2014–17) remained disputed despite a Union Power Ministry direction in 2022.
- Capital: Hyderabad was the common capital only for ten years (till June 2024), while AP had to build Amaravati from scratch with central support under Section 94.
- Rebuilding institutions: AP had to recreate a secretariat, universities and corporations, relying on the promises of the Thirteenth Schedule, such as new national educational institutions.
3. Way forward
- Time-bound settlement: the Union Home Ministry can facilitate negotiations, building on the official-level committees the two states formed in 2024.
- Neutral resolution: expert arbitration for unresolved Schedule IX and X cases, instead of prolonged litigation.
- Fiscal support: Finance Commission grants and central assistance to offset the revenue loss.
A cooperative-federal approach can settle these bifurcation legacies and let both states grow.
The other choice in Q10
Answer either one in the exam.
- Q10(b)Examine the principles envisaged under Schedule Eleven of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act 2014, with reference to the functioning of the river management boards.
10 marks · United Andhra Pradesh and the 2014 Split · AP Reorganisation Act 2014: assets, employees, water
Every model answer on these pages is free to read. The Tool Kit adds four PDF books for Mains Papers I–IV: every previous question sorted by syllabus, with practice questions. It is in the ₹149 All-in-One Pass, with every previous paper of every exam on the site, practice quizzes, timed tests, mock test series and study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking