
Photo: Paddy fields near Eluru, iMahesh, CC BY-SA 4.0
APPSC Group-I Mains 2020 · Paper IV
2020 Paper IV · Q10(a): model answer
Economy & Development of India and Andhra Pradesh · Industry and business (India and AP). Held in December 2020 (Notification 27/2018).
What are the critical issues that must be addressed before implementing disinvestment policy?
Syllabus: Industry and business (India and AP) · Public sector companies, disinvestment and privatisation
DisinvestmentStrategic saleValuation and transparencyStakeholder interests
Disinvestment is the sale of government equity in public sector enterprises, either a minority stake or a strategic sale with transfer of management. It began in 1991-92 and was guided by the Rangarajan Committee (1993), the Disinvestment Commission (1996) and now DIPAM (2016) and the New Public Sector Enterprise Policy (2021). Past sales show that success depends on preparing the ground first.
1. Clarity of purpose
- Clear objective: decide whether the aim is efficiency or revenue, and separate strategic sectors (minimum presence) from non-strategic ones (exit).
- Use of proceeds: proceeds should fund capital assets (National Investment Fund, 2005), not the revenue deficit, since selling family silver to pay running costs leaves the state poorer.
- Method: choose between minority sales (offer for sale, IPOs such as LIC's in 2022) and strategic sales, depending on whether management control should change.
2. Process issues
- Fair valuation and transparency: value land and brands properly, use open competitive bidding with independent valuers, and avoid controversies like BALCO (2001) and Centaur Hotel.
- Timing and investor interest: BPCL's strategic sale was dropped in 2022 after bidders withdrew.
- Restructuring before sale: Air India's debt was moved to a special-purpose vehicle before its sale to the Tata group (January 2022).
- Avoid sales between PSUs, such as ONGC buying HPCL (2018), which only move money between government pockets.
- Institutional oversight: a Core Group of Secretaries on Disinvestment and a ministerial Alternative Mechanism oversee strategic sales, which adds checks and credibility.
3. Stakeholders and safeguards
- Public and regional sentiment: enterprises with strong regional or emotional value need consultation with the State and the public before a sale is announced.
- Employees: job security, VRS, pensions and reservations, with union consultation; resistance is lower when workers are assured of their rights in the sale agreement.
- Regulation: sector regulators and the Competition Commission must prevent public monopolies from becoming private monopolies, so that consumers gain from efficiency.
- Legal clearances: the Supreme Court (2003) held that HPCL and BPCL, nationalised by law, could be privatised only with Parliament's approval.
| Case | Issue | Lesson |
|---|---|---|
| BALCO (2001) | Valuation controversy | Independent valuation, open bidding |
| HPCL and BPCL (2003) | Nationalised by law | Parliament's approval needed |
| ONGC–HPCL (2018) | One PSU buying another | No real change of ownership |
| Air India (2022) | Heavy debt | Restructure before sale |
| BPCL (2022) | Bidders withdrew | Timing and investor interest |
4. Andhra Pradesh angle
The strategic sale of the Visakhapatnam Steel Plant, approved in principle in 2021, met strong resistance because the plant is tied to the 1966 "Visakha Ukku – Andhrula Hakku" movement. In January 2025 the Centre approved an ₹11,440 crore revival package instead. The case shows that public sentiment and regional history must be weighed along with balance sheets.
Disinvestment should be a transparent, consultative means to efficiency, not an end in itself.
The other choice in Q10
Answer either one in the exam.
- Q10(b)What are the challenges faced by the industrial sector of Andhra Pradesh? Throw light on the strategies created to face these challenges.
10 marks · Industry and business (India and AP) · AP's industrial policy, incentives, corridors, MSMEs and exports
Every model answer on these pages is free to read. The Tool Kit adds four PDF books for Mains Papers I–IV: every previous question sorted by syllabus, with practice questions. It is in the ₹149 All-in-One Pass, with every previous paper of every exam on the site, practice quizzes, timed tests, mock test series and study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking